Just Deceits
A HISTORICAL COURTROOM MYSTERY
© 2008 by Michael Schein, all rights reserved
Bennett & Hastings Publishing - Release date: September 15, 2008
Consider what you think justice requires, and decide accordingly. But never give your reasons; for your judgment will probably be right, but your reasons will certainly be wrong.
- Lord Mansfield (1705 - 1793), Chief Justice of the King's Bench
PROLOGUE
The First of October, sharply cold. Just a girl, really, she seeks comfort
against the wrenching carriage ride in the warmth of her big sister’s arms, and
finds it as she always has. The
rutted, half-frozen lanes leading to Glenlyvar are determined to shake out her
bowels, but she fights back, sucking herself into a ball, focusing now on the
blurred sunshine outside the window, now on the tempest within. Upon arrival she must lie down, not
like this, not like that, not here, not there, for there is no surcease inside
this skin. Up the narrow stairs,
through the outer chamber, bolt the door to the inner chamber, muffle the cries
between the spotless sheets.
The cries! oh Lord such cries as fly unbidden from the entrails. Cries that would freeze a wolf in its tracks, sour milk in the teat, tauten vestigial hackles. Sister dear, where are you? Laudanum, be quick about it! So bitter it is sweet again then bitter then bitterest. No oblivion, just another ocean of nausea. Sister, where are you? Brother, is that you? Medicine, now! No, not that, no – you know what I need. Not so bitter, not so bad, it goes down greedy smooth then turns to broken glass in the womb.
Sister, hold my hand, sister? Brother? Take my hand and squeeze with all your strength. If you love me, really love me, you will help me now.
PART ONE:
PRETRIAL PROCEEDINGS
Chapter 1
Counsel for
the Defense
1.
Straight in the saddle, at a canter not a
gallop, he rode as a gentleman should. Boots spit shined, breeches starched,
frock coat tight, waistcoat tighter, he took the ground between himself and the
Cumberland County Courthouse like enemy territory. His sharp dismount tossed dark locks from darker eyes to
reveal features at once frozen and roiling. Ignoring the handful of geezers stuck like toadstools to the
courthouse's tobacco-stained stoop, he bounded up the steps and executed an
abrupt about face, startling one octogenarian who stood too close. To the no one in particular assembled,
and to all Virginia which in 1793 was damn near everyone, he said with all the
dignity he could muster through his rage:
“I am Richard Randolph of Bizarre. My character has lately been impugned
by accusations of crimes at which humanity revolts. My wife is humiliated; the
good name I would pass to my innocent baby son has been trampled in the
gutter. I cannot refute these
vicious smears by private suits against their authors; for every one silenced
ten more would appear. Slander, to
be refuted, must be confronted openly, here in the sight of God. If the crimes imputed to me were true,
then my life and my sacred honor would justly be forfeit to the Commonwealth of
Virginia. But I pledge that there
is no truth to these slanders, none!
Therefore I demand to be tried before a jury of this County on the
charge of infanticide. And mark
this well – I will clear my name!”
Done with this extraordinary declamation,
Mr. Randolph produced a handwritten version of the same, to which he had not
referred once while speaking, and shoved it through a link in one of the many
wrist cuffs bolted to the front of the courthouse for use on auction day. He departed as smartly as he arrived,
save only for the tobacco juice on his boots, and the triumph in his eyes.
“Damn fool,” said the geezer he’d nearly
trampled, “they’ll hang him now, fer sure.”
Based on actual trial notes and letters, Schein skillfully tells the tale of Randolph first cousins, members of Virginia's leading family, who face the death penalty in 1793 for infanticide and adultery, and are defended by future first U.S. Supreme Court Chief Justice John Marshall, himself a Randolph.
Schein, who refuses to provide easy answers to the trial's central mystery, lucidly explores Marshall's internal struggles with ambition and poverty, an ardent desire to shape and to work honorably within a nascent legal system, and strained family relationships.
Schein, a
Return to Just Deceits.
© 2008 Michael Schein, all rights reserved.